Answer:
If you are considered a large servicer (under the Mortgage Servicing Rules), you must pay it even if the escrow account will go deficient. If you are not a large servicer, you don’t have to pay it. However, if you force-place the insurance, the charge cannot exceed what the insurance would have cost if paid out of the escrow account. Beyond that, it becomes a contractual issue.
-----------------------------
Learn more about David Dickinson’s webinar Escrows: All you need to know