I'll never watch american idol again- its all based on the looks or in the case of Scott well I don't know in his case- its unreal- never again.

Constantine, Anthony, and Vonzell in the bottom 3? What's up with that? Of those 3, Constantine should go, but Vonzell was better than Carrie and Scott was worse than everyone.

the fat beast lives to see another week, amazing

I'm posting anon because I don't want you to think bad of me, but I said today at work that there is a "fat,ugly and off key" club out there ( and no I'm not slim and great looking") who is voting for an underdog, and he is a "dog". What a shame, he has absolutely no talent. He has no stage presence! What the heck is the problem with the American Public? Well I guesss that this just proves the dumming down of America! I do not want to be associated with such a stupid group of Americans.

I still cannot believe that Scott not only survived but was in the top three! America, stop subjecting yourself to this abuse!!

I just heard on my local radio station that speculation is that Constantine was NOT the lowest vote getter, but this was a ploy to get him off the show because of his band's record deal announced last week or the week before. AI didn't want to look bad because they knew about the record deal and still let Constantine continue. Makes sense to me. What doesn't make sense, is why Scott, who was absolutely terrible, wasn't in the bottom three.

Constantine is a horrible singer and performer. That is why he got voted off!!!!
That guy is the cheesiest singer that I have ever seen!!

What about how Paula behaved? She was crying and consoling Constantine's mother? I couldn't believe that she became that emotional and didn't try to hide it.

Blech! Constantine! Blech!

I'm am so angry that Vonzell was in bottom 3 and not Scott, it's a total farce and makes me not want to watch anymore! It is a popularity contest, clearly not based on talent......Scott sounds the same on every single song he sings...bad...it's ridiculous! I was not overly upset that Const. left, was never a fan of his anyway. He did look completely shocked though that he was going home. Paula, what can I say, she makes me physically sick, she really needs to go, I've never seen such a drama queen as Ms. Paula.

I like the show again! And yes, EGB, I did vote for Scott (first time I voted) as I explained yesterday.

I have been waiting for that cheese ball to get knocked down a few pegs, and it was priceless! And say what you want about Scott, but all I know is "good for him" for going to the group with Carrie and Bo when asked. He did that without looking like a cocky SOB, whereas Constantine slithered over there like he was taking his rightful place...and then to lose to Anthony - oh, I was having a ball. What made it even better is that Paula sobbed like the miserable wretch she is, and hugged her celebrity look-alike - Consantine's Mom!

I was thinking just that when she started behaving that way. It will be interesting to see what they expose here in the near future. I wonder if she will carry on like that when the next idol gets booted off.

Scott being in the top 3 is almost as shocking as John Kerry finishing in the top 2 in the last presidential election!!!

You should only be allowed to vote one time per show- and have a 900 #- maybe then you would knock some people on their butts who only vote for the looks, or the sex appeal-there is nothing wrong with being different-but there is something wrong when you can't sing and get the votes.
Scott has tons and tons of fans from Cleveland Ohio- every night the news has a segment on something to do with Scotty- whether it be his family, friends whatever- they play it up big and it goes on and on. Reaction to the action- every single night- Oh well who cares! They all will do something with their voices after this crooked show is off.

that was me above- I thought I was signed in-
now I'll sign out-

I agree with the one vote per customer issue. It is why I have never voted on that show...

I was shocked that it was Constantine instead of Anthony. I was sitting there all happy because I thought Anthony was going for sure, but he skated by one more time. Constantine's performance the night before was bad, although I do think he had performed well up until that point.

I voted for Bo and my fiance voted for Vonzell. Even bigger shocker that she was in the bottom three! I think popularity does have a lot to do with it, but then again, Constantine was popular with the ladies, teeny boppers, or what have you, and he got the boot. You just never know.

I did not see the results show. I am so GLAD Scott is still in the running. Top 5 he will get a record deal apparently America see that the boy has talent and he has a lot of odds against him, but he can sing. It will be a tough one to call. My top three Bo, Carrie, Vonzell. You might be surprised Vonzell may go next week, remember Latoya London, pretty girl nice voice but didn't beat out the awful Jasmine Trias. So we will see, YEAH for SCOTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

With Bo having the edge in the split rocker vote, the schmaltz vote (Anthony) won.

Celine Dion? I don't even like her songs when she over-sings them. In fact, I probably like less when she over-sings them.

I thought this was supposed to be about who's the best singer and the best stage personality. I would think you'd want to vote for somebody that you'd actually plunk down some cash to see them perform or to buy a CD. Voting for somebody because you feel sorry for them or you think they need a boost for their ego is just a wasted vote, imo. And I don't think you're really doing them any favors. After they're off the show, they will not have the adoration they've come to expect. Does anybody remember Justin from the first show? He was not a great singer but he was cute. He got the "cute" vote; not the "wow, you're a good singer and I'd pay to hear you sing" vote. Now that he's not on the show anymore, he spun completely off the face of the earth.